Thursday, 16 May 2019

Book 13: 1 Chronicles

Let's start off with the laziest narrative I've ever seen, and the bible sets a pretty damn high bar: A list of hundreds of names in chronological order. I kid you not, the first nine chapters (30%) are just names, no verbs or adjectives, just hundreds of names of men.

I already hate this.

All the notable people from Jewish history, every single one. All the way from Adam the first man, to Azel, descendent of Saul. Saul who was predecessor to David.

Being some sort of masochist, I did not skip through any of this text just so one day I will be able to say I've read the entire bible.

In the first 9 chapters of this book, there are 886 male names, 25 female names, and 25 names for nations or people groups. I couldn't name even 1% from memory, and I just read it. (I did consult an outside source for this count, I'm not that much of a masochist).

Probably this is an important resource for someone somewhere, but why is this in the bible, a book I thought to be about god teaching man morality? This book along with the previous ones often suggests learning about these kings by reading the annals of the kings of Israel and Judah, Why even waste page space on these histories in the bible?



The remaining 20 chapters are a repetition in its entirety of the story of David. The same anecdotes from the books of Samuel, minus his most famous story versus Goliath. At least the details seem to match, so that's something positive, I guess...

The largest difference with previous books is that these anecdotes are followed, not by lists of subsequent rulers, but by even longer lists of secondary and tertiary characters. Priests, warriors, minor heroes.

I guess since this is Chronicles, you could treat this book as an index.

Bible top tip


If someone somewhere mentions a name that sounds biblical, ctrl-F in Chronicles, you'll be sure to find it. Yeah, I know, a pretty crappy tip...but this entire book is just retreading old ground.



Excerpt from a transcribed prayer:

1 Chronicles 16:34
Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good;
    his love endures forever.

Empirically false, based on evidence gathered from the bible. God is consistently portrayed as mean, petty, and vengeful.



Ultimately, one thing I have to begrudgingly concede is that this retelling of the same tales wasn't completely pointless, as it clear up some of my confusion as to god's last fit of anger against king David. He was angry at him performing a census of his people...But why that is a bad thing, only god knows.


Morality: I'm teetering between just referring to the books of Samuel, or giving it a N/A null value, so I guess I'll do the Solomon thing of cutting the score in half.

Morality: 0/A [does not compute]


Whoops, I broke maths.


Storytelling: All in all, since I've been getting used to the story structure of the bible, I wasn't too annoyed by this book as I didn't need to really put my brain into it.
This explains why this review is comparatively much shorter than previous instalments, although the book itself is longer than usual.
However, on its own merits, it is much more boring than Samuel, and I gave those books 8/10, so bearing in mind the atrocious first nine books:

Storytelling: 5/10


If you who are reading this review are interested in the story of David and want it straight from the horse's mouth, you have a choice to make. I recommend choosing the lesser of two evils: read Samuel, not 1 Chronicles. It's the same stories, but chronicles had a lot more index keeping. A proper tl;dr can be done in 6 words: David was the greatest warrior king.

1 comment:

  1. I appreciate that you stuck with it, even through the credits.

    ReplyDelete