Friday, 31 May 2019

Book 15: Ezra



The Jewish kingdoms have long since fallen when Cyrus, king of Persia and ruler over a great empire including pretty much all the Jewish people, decides to enact some freedom of religion rules. The king has the (jewish) people of Judah rebuild a temple in Jerusalem, he even dusts off some gold plates that Nebuchadnezzar had taken from Solomon's old temple there.

The Jews get excited, and start enumerating their sub-populations. Sadly, some families don't pass muster, as they can't prove their lineage to be pure, and are excluded from Israel forever.
Some non-abrahamic people would also like to help with rebuilding the temple since they have worshipped this same god for a long time now.
These outsiders are promptly told to get stuffed, no goy allowed! Purebloods only!

Hey, when you don't have the power to genocide other peoples, the least you can do is a rudimentary but thorough eugenics program and a solid policy of excluding outsiders.


Since rebuilding a temple somehow has to take several generations, and politics tend to change over time, king Xerxes of Persia forcibly stops all construction on this project. Wary of the Jews deciding to also rebuild the walls of Jerusalem and starting a revolt. Fortunately, two generations later, under king Darius, an old authorisation from king Cyrus is found in the archives, and work on the capital of Judah, Jerusalem, resumes.

As you can see, this is about as exciting as the opening crawl of Star Wars: Episode I. Maybe they should have started a vote of no confidence on King Artaxerxes, son of Xerxes.

Eventually, the temple of Solomon was rebuilt in Jerusalem, and Ezra the teacher & priest for whom this book is named, is put in charge of budgeting. Exciting!

A bunch of people travel to Jerusalem from exile, with a whole lot of offerings. Gold, bronze, cattle. But Tssk tssk, during their exile, they had married foreign women, that won’t do. After careful praying it is decided that all the wives and children from those unions must be kicked out. Chosen people only!

Storytelling: 5.4/10




Morality: 1/10


Like a little boy's treehouse with a "no girls allowed" sign, Jerusalem is only for pure blood Jews, no half-breeds(-1), no converts(-1). And you better have your papers ready, or bureaucracy will get ya! (-1). But at least the Jewish people are too weak to do perform any genocides.

Wednesday, 29 May 2019

Book 14: 2 Chronicles

As the previous book rehashed the story of king David previously told in Samuel, it follows that this book be a retelling of the stories of Kings: Solomon, Rehoboam, Jeroboam, and the rest. All the way until the fall of Jerusalem. There really isn't that much new information to impart, so this review will be short.
One notable absence is the entertaining story of of Elijah mage prophet, and his son Elisha whom I like to call beta versions Jesus. They're not even mentioned by name despite previously having large parts of the books of Kings dedicated to their little adventures.

Although this is once again repeating stories just told two books ago, and glosses over many tales, there are more details and numbers on the mundane lives of many generations of kings, making this retelling about the same length as 1 and 2 Kings combined. For a casual reader like me...there’s really almost nothing new or interesting enough to take note of. For a historian, maybe, but even for a Rabbi...who cares about these names with no dates attached?

At the very end, though, the timeline extends slightly, The chosen people are under the yoke of The Babylonians, until the Persian empire takes over (don’t ask me for specific time spans, this is not the strong suit of these history books), and the Persian ruler decides to rebuild a Jewish temple in Jerusalem.
For the first time in several books spanning many centuries, the laws of Moses are mentioned. It seems the Jews are really serious about not screwing around with false idols from now on.



BIBLE TOP TIP


Faith healing only works if you don't go to the doctor.

2 Chronicles 16:12-13
In the thirty-ninth year of his reign Asa was afflicted with a disease in his feet. Though his disease was severe, even in his illness he did not seek help from the Lord, but only from the physicians.
Then in the forty-first year of his reign Asa died and rested with his ancestors.




Storytelling: 3/10


Take out the the good bits, the mythical stories of Elijah and Elisha, out of the books kings, and once again restate the same history. Repetitions is really the bread and butter of the Old Testament.

Morality: 3/10


If you're sick, go see a doctor.

Thursday, 16 May 2019

Book 13: 1 Chronicles

Let's start off with the laziest narrative I've ever seen, and the bible sets a pretty damn high bar: A list of hundreds of names in chronological order. I kid you not, the first nine chapters (30%) are just names, no verbs or adjectives, just hundreds of names of men.

I already hate this.

All the notable people from Jewish history, every single one. All the way from Adam the first man, to Azel, descendent of Saul. Saul who was predecessor to David.

Being some sort of masochist, I did not skip through any of this text just so one day I will be able to say I've read the entire bible.

In the first 9 chapters of this book, there are 886 male names, 25 female names, and 25 names for nations or people groups. I couldn't name even 1% from memory, and I just read it. (I did consult an outside source for this count, I'm not that much of a masochist).

Probably this is an important resource for someone somewhere, but why is this in the bible, a book I thought to be about god teaching man morality? This book along with the previous ones often suggests learning about these kings by reading the annals of the kings of Israel and Judah, Why even waste page space on these histories in the bible?



The remaining 20 chapters are a repetition in its entirety of the story of David. The same anecdotes from the books of Samuel, minus his most famous story versus Goliath. At least the details seem to match, so that's something positive, I guess...

The largest difference with previous books is that these anecdotes are followed, not by lists of subsequent rulers, but by even longer lists of secondary and tertiary characters. Priests, warriors, minor heroes.

I guess since this is Chronicles, you could treat this book as an index.

Bible top tip


If someone somewhere mentions a name that sounds biblical, ctrl-F in Chronicles, you'll be sure to find it. Yeah, I know, a pretty crappy tip...but this entire book is just retreading old ground.



Excerpt from a transcribed prayer:

1 Chronicles 16:34
Give thanks to the Lord, for he is good;
    his love endures forever.

Empirically false, based on evidence gathered from the bible. God is consistently portrayed as mean, petty, and vengeful.

Wednesday, 15 May 2019

Book 12: 2 Kings

Elijah is now a high level mage who summons fireballs from heaven to incinerate soldiers who are sent after him. Very early in this book though, as he is walking with his son Elisha:

2 kings 2:11
 they were walking along and talking together, suddenly a chariot of fire and horses of fire appeared and separated the two of them, and Elijah went up to heaven in a whirlwind.



Fortunately for Elisha, son of Elijah, he looted the body to pick his cloak of Holy Moses that can part any water that stands in one's way (but probably comes with a -2 Charisma modifier). Elisha ended up becoming a pretty good mage himself:

2 kings 2:23-24
From there Elisha went up to Bethel. As he was walking along the road, some boys came out of the town and jeered at him. “Get out of here, baldy!” they said. “Get out of here, baldy!”
He turned around, looked at them and called down a curse on them in the name of the Lord. Then two bears came out of the woods and mauled forty-two of the boys.


If you're wondering why nobody else, not even God's favourite bro David had magic powers like this! Well, stop asking questions, this is the bible, not some tale of logic and reason.

The three Jewish kings (yeah I know, I thought there were two, but now there's a new one, king of Elom) go to war against Moab. While crossing the desert, they suddenly remember they don't bring any water...again. What is it with Jews and lack of planning for desert crossings?
No matter, they go to ask Elisha for counsel, and on his advice, dig pits in the ground where water starts flowing...not the best miracle, 3/10. Elisha stumbles a bit with a handful of less impressive and rehashed miracles borrowed from his dad, like the infinite oil trick, but eventually finds his own voice.



Mostly, though, being a prophet with magical gifts, the power gets to his head, and he starts doing random miracles without asking anyone's permission or advice. At one point, he oversteps his bounds by making a woman become pregnant...no, not like that. The baby dies, the woman asks to just be left alone, but Elisha resurrects it.
He un-poisons a suspect stew, makes some more infinite bread, cures a leper, and refuses payment for his deeds...this is starting to sound a bit too much like beta version Jesus. Jesus without the compassion, since Elisha afflicts his servant with leprosy after the later steps out of line and gives in to greed.

Upon being attacked by enemy troops, he decides not to act like his dad whose favoured spell was  fireballs from heaven. Instead, Elisha renders the enemies blind, captures them, restores their eyesight, and instructs his followers to not execute the prisoners. Good Job, prophet!

As war wages on, the enemy Arameans are besieging Samaria, and the situation is getting so bad the survivors are resorting to methodical cannibalism, first my son, then your son, and all the way down the line. It takes a while for Elisha to get off his butt, however, he ends up easily breaking the siege.

Bible Top Tip

If you're playing DnD, and devise a cunning plan to use a  level 0 cantrip of prestidigitation to fake the sound of hooves and chariots in order to make a heavily entrenched enemy flee in panic, and your GM says that's stupid, tell him a prophet mage made it happen in the bible.

Moving on...
2 Kings 8:1
Now Elisha had said to the woman whose son he had restored to life, “Go away with your family and stay for a while wherever you can, because the Lord has decreed a famine in the land that will last seven years.”

Uh, first of all, why is this famine happening? There's no correlating human actions and god's response...unless bad harvests can just happen without supernatural intervention...But who's be blind enough to believe that, haha.
Second...what does she care? She has a bottomless flask of oil and a bottomless bowl of flour, she'll never go hungry!
Third, Elisha can just create infinite food out of thin air, maybe if he put some effort into it for once, he could help his fellow countrymen instead of spending time making axeheads float on water (yes that happened).

Bah humbug.


As has been routine in the past four books of the bible, these entertaining mythical sounding anecdotes are just palate cleansers for boring politics, names of kings, locations of battles, yawn. I'll spare you the trouble.

However, Elisha's next good deed is what we in the enlightened 21st century would call
...ahem...epic prank bro lololol.
"Prophet disciple, take this jug of oil, pour it on a military commander's head, and declare him to be king of Israel, then run away". And so he did, and so there was more civil war and regicide during this ongoing war against the Arameans.
It's just a prank, bro!

Let's leave Elisha behind for a while to talk about Jehu, this king though prank. (No it wasn't actually a prank, it just reads that way), amongst other slaughters, he finally destroys the Tempe of Baal in Jerusalem so the Israelites can go back to their own god for good.

2 kings 10:27
They demolished the sacred stone of Baal and tore down the temple of Baal, and people have used it for a latrine to this day.

"Good job", said god to Jehu, "You and your descendent will rule for four generations!".
Of course, we have to follow tropes here, so Jehu turned out to somehow not be holy enough in some way. Because of his poor leadership as king...no, wait... Unrelated to anything any human did, god himself reduced the size of the land of Israel.


Remember!

Your actions have no consequences.

Only god can affect the world.

This would be the new slogan for this post-genocial era.

Some decades later, The great big temple in Jerusalem is in need of repairs, so the priesthood manages to collect money unsupervised for 23 years, until someone noticed the temple is still in disrepair. Bureaucracy to the rescue! The money is divided by accountants, instead stuffing the pockets of priests or being spent to buy golden plates, the money is rightly used to pay workers...and then sadly to bribe an enemy army.

But even with all these destructions of false idols and rebuilding of good temples, the bad times continue for Israel. Details can be found in the annals of the kings of Judah and of Israel, but long sorry short, all the kings continue "doing evil in the eyes of the lord".

The timeline gets very muddled, but eventually beta version Jesus aka the prophet Elisha dies, and performs one last miracle, resurrecting a dead man who had fallen on Elisha's bones.

An old rule is mentioned in passing :
2 Kings 14:6
Yet he did not put the children of the assassins to death, in accordance with what is written in the Book of the Law of Moses where the LORD commanded: "Parents are not to be put to death for their children, nor children put to death for their parents; each will die for their own sin."

This contradicts what god directly made happen to Solomon's son, in the previous book, 1 Kings.

Hundreds of years go by with the usual list of kings and duration of their reigns. This king here liked assassinations, this one there liked bribes, another one killed all pregnant women in a city, yet another sacrificed his son on an altar to a competing god. But the important bit is they all did "evil in the eyes of the lord" by continuing to worship the wrong things, so the dark times continued.

The End of the Beginning of the Beginning of the End

Finally, king Hezekiah is in line to rule Judah, and he "does good the eyes of the lord", by smashing all nonconforming places of worship, so monotheism can get a grip once again.

But war still does not go well, Israel and most of the surrounding non-Jewish peoples have fallen to the Assyrians (Hezekiah is king of Judah, not Israel). He is forced to strip gold and silver from the lord's temples in order to pay war tributes. At the gates of Jerusalem, the Assyrian commander sent by his king makes a grand and convincing speech in Hebrew, for some reason transcribed in its bombastic entirety. He tells the people living there to stop this war, since Israel nor Judah have no more money or fighting men, give in to peace under Assyrian rule. He even has the cheek to say the lord knows he is here, as he was sent by the lord.

Ooh, what will the faithful do now? Well if you'd paid attention, you would know they did nothing. Only god can affect the world with his actions.

2 kings 19:35-36
That night the angel of the Lord went out and put to death a hundred and eighty-five thousand in the Assyrian camp. When the people got up the next morning—there were all the dead bodies!
So Sennacherib king of Assyria broke camp and withdrew. He returned to Nineveh and stayed there.

 Bim, bam, done.

Just as I thought this drudgery was changing pace with Hezekiah's favour in the Lord's eyes...He dies, and his son rebuilds the heathen temples in Jerusalem...groan.
Sonny boy does all the stupid things imaginable, consults mediums, erects heathen altars inside god's temples, sacrifices his son to Baal, etc.

Someone should really invent a system of government that isn't based on heredity...If only there was a wise and all-powerful supernatural being that people routinely talked with, but nowhere in the bible is that kind of god mentioned. (Note, I said wise. Jewish god had never been wise.)

Instead, this happens:

2 kings 21:12-13
This is what the Lord, the God of Israel, says: I am going to bring such disaster on Jerusalem and Judah that the ears of everyone who hears of it will tingle.
I will stretch out over Jerusalem the measuring line used against Samaria and the plumb line used against the house of Ahab. I will wipe out Jerusalem as one wipes a dish, wiping it and turning it upside down.

Oh boy was he ticked off this time! But for a long while, nothing happens. Time must flow differently up there in heaven.

Several decades later, a new virtuous king gets his turn at running Judah. New king Josiah decides to do a religious cleansing, and do it properly this time. Destroy all false idols, dig up graves and burn the bones on altars to desecrate them, get rid of the male prostitutes in all the temples of all the cities he can reach. No more half measures.
To top it all off, he reinstated passover and other Jewish rituals which nobody had observed since the days of Moses, thousands of years ago.

Josiah was the holiest king that ever was or ever will be, so sayeth the bible. King David, greatest king in history, get fucked. King Solomon, wisest king of all time? You too get fucked.

Ah, finally this interminable procession of kings and their pretty squabbles ends...oh, what's this? Still two chapters left?
...fine
...
I SAID FINE!



So guess what, Josiah dies. Then guess what, his son is now king and he "does evil in the eyes of the lord". OH COME ON! WE'VE BEEN OVER THIS SO MANY TIMES! sigh. So this king dies, his son the new king is also evil, in addition to now being a puppet of the pharaoh, and when Egypt is conquered by Babylon, he becomes a puppet to Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon...Oh please, lord, let these kings die so this book can end!

Thankfully, the lord answered my prayer. This latest and last incompetent king tries to do something by himself, resulting in the sack Jerusalem. The Jewish kings and heirs are dead. All hail Babylon, all hail Nebuchadnezzar, ruler over all Babylon, Egypt, Israel and Judah! Truly only a man with such a great name and empire could lend his glory to a 15 litre champagne bottle.



Now for the scores:

Morality: Starting from a baseline of 5/10, adding or subtracting points accordingly.

Elijah says not to execute prisoners. +1 morality.
Bypassing the priest's greed and overdone displays of opulence in the temple in favour of paying the workers. +1
Condemning human sacrifice, along with anything the Baalites do +1
Continually hammering that nothing any human does has any consequences -5

Morality: 3/10


Storytelling:
Elisha's anecdotes: +3
Repetitive list of kings, telling the reader to read more in the annals of Israel or Judah. -1
Extremely muddy timeline for a history book -1
predictable and cyclical character archetypes -1
Actually making me feel emotion at the end, even if it was anger: grudging +1

Storytelling: 6/10

Phew I'm finally done with these four interminably long books of kingly chronicles. I truly don't know what the bible has next in store for me, but if I say I'll take anything as long as it's not a royal genealogy, I have a feeling I'll regret my words.

Tuesday, 14 May 2019

Book 11: 1 Kings

David is old, gets a new virgin to keep him warm...why this is even mentioned, your guess is as good as mine, but that's this book's opening line.

Obviously, it is now time to find a successor to king David, and obviously, there is much quarreling on the matter. Surprisingly, David voicing his opinion quickly resolves things, and his son Solomon becomes the new king.

Solomon takes the reins of his reign in a manly fashion, does the usual political housekeeping, some executions, a handful of exiles, a reshuffling of the military leadership, pretty typical new king stuff.
However, Solomon is more clever than the typical ruler. He prays to god and asks god for wisdom. God being easily impressed by his unselfish request, grants him the greatest wisdom that has ever been...and riches...and long life and a long reign.

Bible top tip


Humility, even false humility is the way to great riches and blessings from god (If there are no more genocides to be done). Don't be afraid to ask for selfish stuff as long as you are clever about asking it humbly.

Solomon the wise




Two women had babies, one baby died, and both were fighting over whose baby was the live one.
Solomon declared "cut the live baby in two, so both women get equal shares" at which point the living boy's real mother cried in horror and pleaded for the baby to be given to the other woman. Solomon of course gave the baby to her instead, having proved to be the real mother.
Pretty good trick, whose only flaw is that's it's too famous to be impressive anymore. 10/10.
Sadly we don't get many more such tales.

For the first time, this is a tale of peace time. Ben Hurr is name dropped, there are no more genocides or wars, which is a welcome change for the reader. Instead, Solomon's kingdom is vast and plentiful and grows ever more so. He receives yearly tribute of 666 gold talents among other things, and in his palace, everything that can be made of gold is gold. Nothing is made of silver since his great wealth and wisdom had made silver "as plentiful as stone".

Solomon's wisdom was unparalleled, a real natural philosopher, although details of his findings are scarce, because this is a book of politics and history. Sadly, excruciating detail is instead spent describing his grand new palace, and the temple housing the ark of the covenant.



Side note, I haven't mentioned it before, but in many books of the bible, spanning hundreds of years of history, the are several instances where a noteworthy monument, temple, house, or stone is mentioned, followed by the phrase "and it stands there to this day". Of course this is funny to read nowadays, because the old Testament is thousands of years old, but also...When was this supposedly written? when was "this day"? Who compiled all these stories? It clearly cannot be writings from the same era as these events, how robust can this possibly be as a source of historical information?
[Wikipedia says the first edition of the book of kings was around the 7th century BCE. however I don't know that, this is a naïve reading of the bible, assuming it all the be divinely inspired and beyond doubt].

Solomon truly is wise, he even manages to deconstruct the pattern that I pointed out in the previous book had been developing:
  1. god is displeased
  2. unleashes a plague
  3. a pious human asks him to stop
  4. god feels bad and stops.

Here, Solomon preemptively asks god to consider his actions before smiting. A truly visionary move!
Also, god, please don't automatically smite the foreigner who asks about the Jewish god. Cool.

God, in  turn, still being jealous, reminds everyone of the first commandment, the only one that seems to matter, the only one that is repeated ad nauseam. Only worship me and no other god or I'll fuck your shit up.

 20 years of temple building later, some minor international conflicts are mentioned, some borders move, Solomon keeps growing richer, ends up with 700 noble wives and 300 concubines from many countries. All is well, until his wives' influence and life at a cosmopolitan court cloud his wisdom.

The lord Yeeteth and the Lord Yoinketh


I didn't want to add any references or memes that would date this review too severely, but this was too funny not to include

Solomon does the idiotic thing of forgetting the one rule to be followed at all times, and following his foreign wives to occasionally worship at the altars of other gods. DOH!

Ol' boy Yahweh is once again disappointed, and forsakes Solomon. But since he is not entirely predictable, and Solomon's father David was his bro 4 lyphe, god will only destroy Solomon's legacy after the king's death. The kingdom will crumble under Solomon's heir (note: sins of the father passing onto the son).

Hadad, leader of the Edomites, a foreign people who had been defeated by Joab (leader of David's army) is set up to become the new nemesis for Solomon's tale, along with Rezon, another son of a defeated enemy. Unfortunately, although they are given proper back stories and motivations, they are barely heard from again. The third of the "great enemies the lord has raised up against Solomon" is Jeroboam, an Israelite.


Good old bible trope. Jewish leader is mighty, bad things eventually happen, find something where Jewish leader wasn't perfectly holy, blame all the bad things on god taking revenge. Be it plagues or antagonists rising up. Just earlier in this book, Solomon was trying to calm god down, but the same trope repeats itself.
It's also interesting how the Jewish god can so directly influence other people, who have their own gods. Hadad, Rezon and Jeroboam didn't just rise up, god made them rise up to punish Solomon's lineage!
Monotheism, one size fits all explanation. Don't under any circumstances take responsibility for your own actions, do whatever you want, it's all pointless, god will get angry at something eventually. Why even try doing anything.

OK, enough ranting, back to the story.

God promises Jeroboam the kingdom and that he will rule over almost all of Israel, but still leaves some for Solomon, because remember, Solomon's father David and god were bros 4 lyphe.

1 kings 11
41 As for the other events of Solomon’s reign—all he did and the wisdom he displayed—are they not written in the book of the annals of Solomon?

Oh dammit! Should have read that instead of this half-baked kings bible book.
Here ends Solomon's tale, not with a bang but a whimper. I could use a drink... Ah, but speak of the devil!

Jeroboam and other miscellaneous kings

When talking about wine, a Jeroboam means a 3L bottle. Sizes go all the way up to the 15L Nebuchadnezzar

Rehoboam, son and heir to Solomon is a cartoonishly mean and incompetent villain:

1 kings 13
13 The king [Rehoboam] answered the people harshly. Rejecting the advice given him by the elders, 14 he followed the advice of the young men and said, “My father made your yoke heavy; I will make it even heavier. My father scourged you with whips; I will scourge you with scorpions.”

To nobody's surprise, he was quickly eclipsed by Jeroboam, with his only remaining followers being the tribe of Judah in Jerusalem. More details on these reigns can be found in annals of the kings of  Judah and the annals of the kings of Israel, outside of the bible. This is mentioned several times.
Blablabla, there are more civil wars for several more generations, a succession of short lived kings on both sides, the one tribe of Judah and the ten tribes of Israel.

Truly, nobody has learned from history.  Most of the history in Samuel and Kings could be randomly generated with the names of people and cities changed like a mad lib.

In Chapter 16, some moron rebuilt Jericho...but...but... In the last book, I already ranted about refugees from Jericho, the city that should never be rebuilt. It's been rerebuilt now?

Elijah


The next notable character in this neverending story is Elijah, son of ...someone. I don't remember his genealogy, but the important bit is that god likes him. Now this guy's a real character, even in the bible we've never seen the likes of Elijah!
On the lord's orders, he goes to drink from a steam and is fed by ravens who bring him meat and stuff (I assume mostly worms and larvae). He then famously meets a poor widow, who didn't have enough flour and oil to feed him, ooohhhh MIRACLE TIME! Oh boy! It's been centuries since the last clearly supernatural event has happened. God, through Elijah, transforms her meager bowl of flour and jug of oil into bottomless troughs, as much flour and oil as you can eat for the rest of your life. Huzzah!
Maybe this is the origin of Hanukkah, but methinks god was drunk that day and did this to amuse himself.

 Elijah the prophet has enough of the heathen ways the Israelites have fallen into under the latest bad king Ahab, and challenges the Baalite prophets to a battle of the gods. The 450 Baal prophets can't get a bull to light on fire by divine power, no matter how hard they try. Elijah, of course, had god light the fire, and the Israelites proceeded to put all Baal worshiper to the sword.

Ahab remains king...for some reason. With the help of his devilish wife Jezebel, he continues being yet another cartoonishly evil and incompetent king as a necessary narrative contrast to Elijah's holiness.

Eventually, Ahab disgracefully dies in battle against the Arameans. At least at this time, his Israelites had a solid alliance with Jehoshaphat, king of Judah, so god's chosen people are kind of sticking together once again.


On to the scores! I'll try to tally these a bit more rigorously this time, let's see if it works.
Starting at a baseline of  5/10, adding or subtracting points accordingly.
With the morality rating, I'm not reviewing how moral god himself is, that battle was lost several books ago. The morality scale is a comparison between my own pre-existing morality and the lessons think the bible is trying to teach me through the actions of humans.

King Solomon, gets +1 morality points for being wise and just.
+1 for getting god to maybe be less of a dick, appeasement.
+1 for not being warmongering.
immediately followed by -3, because it's all moot, no matter what anyone does, god will find a reason to punish them and nullify their accomplishments. This is how I interpreted what I read. It's sad, I thought the Solomon described here was a great man.

Jeroboam was a crappy king, followed by a bunch of other crappy kings, there's nothing new to learn here.

Elijah campaigns hard for a return to a worship of god, and heals the sick, and feeds the hungry, yeah, good, +2.

Morality: 7/10

Let's try the same thing for the narrative. If a story is well told, I yeet points, if it's boring, I'll yoink points.
+3 for cool Solomon anecdotes
-1 for pages upon pages of temple building description
-1 for god yet again saying the same old tired crap about false idols and graven images.
-1 for building up new nemeses for Solomon, and then failing to realise the potential.
+2 for cool Elijah stories.

Storytelling: 7/10


There isn't much resolution at the end of this book but part two of Kings is still upcoming. This book was kind of 3 Samuel. Just continuing mythic tales mixed with history, just with a little bit less combat. All in all, one of the better bible books so far.

Monday, 13 May 2019

Book 10: 2 Samuel

In a nice change of pace, no time is wasted in the beginning of these continued tales of David. An Amalekite comes to David's camp, proclaims he found king Saul dying and mercy-killed him. For his good deed and message bearing David has him killed and writes a poem (fully transcribed in the book) about his friend and enemy Saul. Nice.

Naturally, civil war between the house of Saul and the house of David ensues. However it isn't long before big D kills a bunch of people in a very preachy way, paving the road for him finally being crowned king over all Israel and Judah at age 30. He remained king for 40 years.

Hmmm, we haven't exterminated any peoples in a while. Davey asks god "is it cool if I attack some more philistine?" And god said "cool". What bros those two are. God even goes out of his way to tell Nathan the prophet that David is his bro for life, not like that loser god picked last time, Saul, no no, this time it's serious.

After hard times battling, it's finally time to settle down and for the first time, build a permanent home to house the ark of the covenant. Ooops, not now! Let's have another war interlude. Blood for the blood god.



Strangely, it's now written that the philistines are finally conquered, but not exterminated. The fates of all these peoples who were promised holy doom vary greatly. Davey sometimes methodically kills 2/3rds, or kills all but 1000 men. It all seems both haphazard and clinical, like an obsessive compulsive on methamphetamine.

At some point, some Israelite messengers are sent to Jericho...but I'm quite certain that Jericho was the first of many cities entirely razed to the ground and forbidden from being rebuilt. Back in
Book 6: Joshua 6:26-27

At that time Joshua pronounced this solemn oath: “Cursed before the Lord is the one who undertakes to rebuild this city, Jericho:



“At the cost of his firstborn son

    he will lay its foundations;
at the cost of his youngest
    he will set up its gates.”



So the Lord was with Joshua, and his fame spread throughout the land.


Damn inconsistencies. Can't even trust god to enforce his zeroth commandment: if in doubt, genocide.

As for David, he falls prey to the tediously formulaic story arc every leader in the bible so far has rigidly followed. After his divine anointment, comes his great glory, and after glory comes the goof as he displeases god. All that rise will sooner or later fall.

In the specific case of our pal Davey, he displeases the lord by having sex with a Hittite woman, and conspiring to have her husband be killed in battle.
 So god kills the child born of that union, and Davey is like "whoops, my bad, bro" and good is like "no probs, you still my main dude, you can get more kids with that chick, we good now".
And no lessons were learned that day.

Yet another civil war


Some soap-opera worthy jealous infighting and incest in ol' Davey's family later, his son Absalom decides to weasel himself into politics the only way he knows how: by feigning holiness and amassing an army. Absalom becomes judge, then king in Hebron, Israel, Thereby inflaming a civil war between Judah and Israel and making Ol' holy Davey flee.

A great blabla is made of internal politics, and Ahithophel the great counsellor kills himself because of lack of character development. But apart from him, there is a sudden abundance of florid prose and this little civil war is almost entertaining to read.

David's sympathisers expertly spy on enemy positions and cunningly hide in a well. David's men win a great battle against the army of Israel, with 20,000 men dying. Oh how tragic it is when the chosen people die, not like the justified genocides of other peoples.

In a quite comical scene, the defeated Absalom tries to flee on his donkey, but gets caught in the branches of a tree.



2 Samuel 18:10-11
When one of the men saw what had happened, he told Joab, “I just saw Absalom hanging in an oak tree.”
Joab said to the man who had told him this, “What?"

Joab being a military man and the leader of Davey's army, goes to to finish off Absalom.

When David heard of the death of his son, he is inconsolable, to the point where his commander Joab verbally slaps him, on this day of victory he cares more about his dead traitorous son than his army or the people he rules! Maybe it's time to grow some cojones and ride back to Jerusalem, Davey!
And so David returned to Jerusalem and almost lived happily ever after. He was magnanimous to those who had lost faith in him, and regained the loyalty of most.

One notable dissident was Sheba the Benjamite, who leads the last remaining disgruntled Israelites away, amassing more followers as he traverses the vast lands.
In a short parentheses, David puts the ten concubine he had left to take care of his palace under house arrest, living as widows for the rest of their lives. Why this is mentioned, or why he does this is beyond my comprehension. Maybe the divinely inspired chronicler who wrote these pages felt an urge to mention the existence of women once in a while.

Joab leads David's army in pursuit of Sheba and eventually lays siege to his last hiding place, Abel Beth Maakah. The inhabitants are a bit miffed about this sudden surge by presumably friendly forces in their famously friendly city, so they ask (I'm paraphrasing here):"Joab, WTF?". Upon hearing the explanation, that all this army wants is to hunt down Sheba, the denizens of this peaceful city toss Sheba's severed hear over the walls, resolving the matter.

</civil_war>


Now, in a turn of events that was very surprising to me, some amends have to be made for the unlawful genocide of Gibeonites by king Saul (see 1 Samuel). Because of a famine, seven sons of Saul are sacrificed.
Now technically, although Jews did give up these men, and they were sacrificed to appease the Jewish god, Jews did not make these sacrifices, Gibeonites did. This may be yet another case of finding loopholes in moral laws.

Some more warring against the philistines is mentioned in passing, tying a rather poor narrative bow around the tale of the greatest king who ever was.

Suddenly, David starts singing a song in a very poetic manner about the glory and strength of the lord, and how good of a follower he has been his whole life. It's an entire chapter long, but you can see the tone from the opening verse:
2 Samuel 22:
“The Lord is my rock, my fortress and my deliverer;
my God is my rock, in whom I take refuge,
    my shield and the horn of my salvation.
He is my stronghold, my refuge and my savior."

Bolts of lightning, foundations of the earth, deep waters, trampling the enemies of the lord into dust, etc.
Honestly, a pretty good epic poem, only its placement in this purportedly historical book feels a bit out of place.

Bible top tip


If you're writing a grandiose autobiography, or a history book about a ruler you love, don't be shy, and finish it with an epic poem about holiness and struggle, it sure makes for a memorable ending  crescendo.
However, don't add dull post scripts after that magnificent culmination, that would make it feel like a hastily read legal fine print at the end of  TV commercial for bank loans.

The penultimate chapter is a list of his followers' lesser heroic deeds, feeling like an out of place  paltry post script. Finally, to really destroy the grand ending for this book the poem has set up, this is how the last chapter begins:

2 Samuel 24:1
Again the anger of the Lord burned against Israel, and he incited David against them, saying, “Go and take a census of Israel and Judah.”



Where this sudden anger comes from...we are not told, but once again the typical sequence of events plays out. God makes a plague, goes a bit too far, is asked to stop by a devout human, (in this case our pal Davey), and it's fine after all. Just build an altar of something, make some offerings, it's fine, just fine. It's just part of life.

I guess if this book were a movie, the epic poem in chapters 22 would be the epilogue, chapter 23's long list of side-characters would be the credits, and the sudden unannounced plague would new a sequel-baiting post credits action sequence.

Will there be a sequel, 3-Samuel: Samuel Harder?

Tune in next time to find out!

Morals: 0/10

Same old, same old, mostly bad. War times means war crimes.

Storytelling: 8/10

Not bad at all, especially the second half of this book, above all the epic poem that is chapter 23.