Tuesday, 30 April 2019

Book 9: 1 Samuel

The overarching theme of this book is "history is written by the victors", it's something that has already been established in earlier books, but here it really becomes formulaic.

Bible Top Tip:

How to write a history book, according to the bible:
Take some parchment, leave some blank space at the top, write down historical events, mostly battles.
- Did your side win? Write an intro praising the lord for granting this victory.
- Was your side less than completely successful? Find infinitesimal flaws in the way your leader worshipped, and call him unworthy.
The old trope applies: if your prayers haven't been answered, you didn't pray hard enough and you're a loser, god is infallible.



Hanna got drunk on prayer, until her womb opened up again and she conceived a child: Samuel. Samuel, even as a child was a priestly wunderkind, others were not holy enough, but he knew how to praise the Lord best. This seems like a recurring theme in all religions, and a good way to create new sects. Eli was the judge when Samuel was a child, but he was not holy enough, because nobody ever is, for narrative contrivances.

Samuel the new fashionable prophet gets a whopping two long books to himself. Under Eli's rule, the Israelites lose a major battle, and the ark of the covenant is lost to the philistines. When he hears the news, Eli "fell off" his chair and "accidentally" broke his neck. Make way for the new prophet! As everyone knows from the holy book of Dr. Henry Jones Jr., the ark of the covenant is dangerous to unbelievers, and while there are no Nazis to melt, the ark gives deadly tumours to the philistine, and they have to get rid of it...with offerings of 5 gold rats and 5 gold tumours...naturally.

Ah, glory returns to Israel, let's have some more battling, just to make sure more philistine than Israelites have died, 50 000 killed should do it.

Long fade to black and the book skips ahead skipping ahead from Samuel being a child and the ark being lost for a matter of months, to Samuel being an old man. Since this is his story, and the concept of supporting characters evidently hadn't been invented yet, nobody else is good enough. Even Samuel's sons are dirty little sinners.

The people ask Samuel to give them a king, ending the age of judges, and he obliges them.

Better call Saul!

The humble Saul comes before the prophet Samuel, and the prophet tells him to go to that large gathering of prophets, and you too will become a prophet.

...I was under the impression that prophets are exceedingly rare, and that hunting down soothsayers and other false prophets was commonplace, but I guess not this time. You know the bible, famous for not being very strict on rules and such.

Saul levels up and becomes a prophet, and is made king by Samuel. Good deal for Saul, he only has to gouge out a few eyes to make himself be accepted as divinely appointed ruler.
Not such a good deal for the people though, for some reason asking for a king was evil? But I guess as long as the king is good, it's all good, man, Saul Goodman.

Most of the long tales of warfare throughout these past several books have had increasingly flimsy excuses for military defeats, and they invariably read like post hoc hand-waving explanations. As an example, 1 Samuel 13 WTF, just a few pages ago, Saul was a prophet, with a direct line to god, now suddenly, he...made one offering too many to god, and Samuel tells him his reign will fail, because he did not do exactly as told...but...he's the king...and a prophet...but...Samuel. Honestly, I reread this chapter four times and I can't make head nor tails of it. God and his many many prophets keeps changing the rules. This makes it very difficult to use these books as sources of morality.
But as long as there is genocidal holy war and on the heathens, god is pleased.

Bible top tip:


I want to make myself a T-shirt that says:

When in Doubt
Genocide


But I feel that message would be misunderstood and I'd have to endure being constantly being punched in the face by strangers in the street.


Samuel 15: 2 This is what the Lord Almighty says: ‘I will punish the Amalekites for what they did to Israel when they waylaid them as they came up from Egypt.
3 Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.’”
[...]
7 Then Saul attacked the Amalekites all the way from Havilah to Shur, near the eastern border of Egypt.
8 He took Agag king of the Amalekites alive, and all his people he totally destroyed with the sword.
9 But Saul and the army spared Agag and the best of the sheep and cattle, the fat calves and lambs—everything that was good. These they were unwilling to destroy completely, but everything that was despised and weak they totally destroyed.
10 Then the word of the Lord came to Samuel:
11 “I regret that I have made Saul king, because he has turned away from me and has not carried out my instructions.”

The message is clear. Nothing short of genocide will please the blood god. Therefore, Saul falls from grace, because he did not 100% blindly follow every small detail some other prophet had in his head. I mean, how dare a king make his own decisions, he should clearly be a puppet of the clergy, and love the murder of foreigners as must as his god.
Saul is out, and Jesse is in...the Breaking Bad theme intensifies. Jesse's son is the soon to be most famous of all the kings, David. The meekest but purest son of Jesse.

David and Goliath


Goliath was a philistine, a tank of a man, and as the famous tale goes, he challenged the Israelites to bring out a champion. If he defeated the Israelite champion, Israel would be conquered, and vice-versa. Hey, a nice way to stop attrition by war on both sides.
Of course, the wee lad David threw a stone in Goliath's forehead, killing him. David cut off his
 head, and the Israelites proceed to slaughter all philistine in the area...fair play is not something Israelites cared about.
One may think David versus Goliath is a tale of the cunning overcoming the strong, brains over brawn, but David doesn't show any sign of using his brains, only one lucky shot, followed by conventional warfare. I think the lesson is, once again, if you do as god says, you will win. Do not use your own intellect nor reason.

Saul the disgraced king is envious of the praise the people give David, furious that they attribute him with tens of thousands of heathen kills, and Saul, the king himself, with only thousands. Since Saul fell from god's good graces, he's suddenly painted as a murderous maniac compared to god's new chosen boy wonder (remember, this is only a bad thing if you're doing wrong against other Israelites). He plots to get David killed in war by offering his daughter's hand in marriage if David brings 100 philistine foreskins, but you know how it goes, the hero du jour can't do anything wrong, until god one day probably gets tired of him, so bla bla bla David survives assassination attempts, wins all the battles, both against philistine and against Saul. Yawn, predictable and shallow stories, yet again.

It is interesting to note that the continued assassination attempts by Saul on David are brought on by "an evil spirit from god" it's as if god is bored and is trying to make drama happen with his little human playthings.

For those who may think I'm getting redundant and exaggerating with the whole genocidal theme, behold the actions of David the greatest king of all time
1 Samuel 27:11 He did not leave a man or woman alive to be brought to Gath, for he thought, “They might inform on us and say, ‘This is what David did.’” And such was his practice as long as he lived in Philistine territory.

Conversely, when the philistines conquer a city, they capture the women and children and occupy the city. They are waging a war of defence, not extermination.

We do get a bit of levity in chapter 28, when Saul consults a medium at Endor. I picture a little Ewok soothsayer, gupa nuupa! mana tutu! And the Philistines as stormtroopers or something.



Eventually, Samuel the prophet dies of old age without much fanfare and  later, king Saul loses his last battle and throws himself onto his own sword. There ends his line, tying a nice little bow at the end of this long and eventful book, paving the way for the reign of king David.


Morality: -32 /10

I don't even know anymore, everything is terrible. I'll just add one point to the worst score I've given so far.

Storytelling: 8/10

As usual, some boring parts, and it's getting extremely formulaic, but overall not bad.

Friday, 19 April 2019

Book 8: Ruth

This is a very short book, only 4 chapters compared to the usual 20-30.

Ruth is the widow of a Moabite, who is taken in by a jewish family. this shows that it is indeed possible for a woman to marry into the chosen people, and become a true Israelite.
There's really not much more to tell.

Storytelling: 8/10
short and sweet, although not exactly thrilling.


Morality: 10/10

Nothing to complain about here.

Book 7: Judges

2019-04-18

This book covers several generations directly after Joshua’s death. Since only god can show the way, nobody dares be a leader and the Israelites decide on a group of judges govern them through divine inspiration.

War stories continue, 70 more kings are conquered early on, but instead of wiping the conquered peoples off the face of the earth, the Israelites just cut off the thumbs and big toes of the kings, turning to plunder and enslavement.

For about 40 years, there is peace after Deborah, the only named female judge in the bible kicks some ass in Canaan (all the conquest is in the land called Canaan).

And here is where the moral of the story peeks its head, remember how insistent god was about the 1st commandment, worshipping no other gods? Remember the genocide? Well god likes genocide.
Since newly conquered cities aren’t razed to the ground and anyone who draws breath slaughtered, the heathen shrines are left standing. Soon, many israelites turn away from their god and worship the more convenient idols (remember god hasn't actually done anything miraculous in several hundred years).

“-OY! YOU CUNTS!” said god! (I’m paraphrasing)
“-Who said that?”
“-I TOLD YOU I WAS A JEALOUS GOD! NOW YOU’LL HAVE TO FIGHT YOUR BATTLES WITHOUT ME”
“-did you hear something?”

So the wars of conquest continue, but without god’s blessing, victory is no longer guaranteed nor easy.

Gideon was one of the judges, and he tried to use his keen mind to decide whether to follow the old israelite, or this hip and trendy Baal guy. So he did what any reasonable person would do, asked god do magic tricks. No, not miracles, just...the equivalent of a dungeons and dragons level 0 cantrip...I can’t even make it sound dumber than the actual text, so enjoy:

Judges 6:36-40
Gideon said to God, “If you will save Israel by my hand as you have promised—look, I will place a wool fleece on the threshing floor. If there is dew only on the fleece and all the ground is dry, then I will know that you will save Israel by my hand, as you said.” And that is what happened. Gideon rose early the next day; he squeezed the fleece and wrung out the dew—a bowlful of water.
Then Gideon said to God, “Do not be angry with me. Let me make just one more request. Allow me one more test with the fleece, but this time make the fleece dry and let the ground be covered with dew.”That night God did so. Only the fleece was dry; all the ground was covered with dew.

I’ll be honest, I kind of lost track of the story threads for a while after this.The narration tries to be interesting, it’s full of glorious battles and generations of presumably wise judges, but the characterisations are mostly underdeveloped and forgettable.
One story in particular that would have been nice to know more about is Shibboleth, the spy-detecting word that only true Israelites know how to pronounce. Sadly, just like the tower of Babel in Genesis, the actual tale in the bible is a mere handful of words.


Ah, but then, we come to manlyman Samson! Samson, for the uninitiated, is to ancient Jews what Achilles was to the ancient greeks, an invincible beefcake that conquered all.
To me, he sprung off the page like god incarnate. Now don’t get too excited, if you’ve read the previous episodes of this bible review, you’ll know I don’t hold god in very high regard.
Samson, like god, is powerful, temperamental, and deeply stupid.

In his first adventure, he poses a riddle to 30 of his wedding guests. The trick is, his riddle is unsolvable, because it related to some dumb anecdote that happened to him earlier in his life. The 30 philistine men of course can’t find the answer, because it’s unsolvable, so they manage to get Samson's wife involved, so she can tell extract the answer from Samson himself.
“Gotcha!” cries samson, you can only know the answer if you asked my wife, now I kill all of you!

The Philistine people are obviously not happy about this, so they attack him and kill his wife, who may or may not have married someone else...it’s confusing.. Samson kills 1000 philistines. But whatever happened to “an eye for an eye!?” I hear you ask? Oh silly you, the laws given down by god only apply to other israelites! Other people are not the chosen, so they can be dispatched without second thought.

So, about 1030 people murdered, because Samson is a dick, like his god.


Later in life, while Samson is screwing a prostitute in Gaza (remember, only israelite women are forbidden to be prostituted, god’s morality and laws have easily escapable loopholes), philistines try to ambush him, but since he’s a manlyman, he fights them off.
Samson soon falls in love with a woman and during courtship she asks what his weakness is. Talk about a red flag.

”Tie me down with seven undried bowstrings”, so she does. (kinky?) But, shock and gasp! Philistines were waiting in ambush! Aha, but it was a trick, no bowstrings can hold down Samson. He kills the attackers for he is invincible manlyman.
Any reasonable person would be suspicious by now, but he’s in love, so I’ll forgive his gullibility. However, she repeats that same trick three times, and each time, there are philistines in ambush. Come on Samson, get out of there! After she has tried to murder him three times, he finally tells her what his weakness is, his magical hair! So, predictably, she shaves off his hair, rendering manlyman powerless, and the philistines that were waiting in ambush for the fourth time poke his eyes out and enslave him in the mines.
So, in summary, Samson is a moron, like his god.

Fortunately for him, his enemies are also none too bright, after his hair has grown back during years of slavery and his manlyman powers are back, he’s brought to a temple where he brings the roof down, crushing and killing many more people, including himself.

Storytelling: 8/10

At least his stories were mildly entertaining to read, although the narration is as stilted as always and the protagonist was deeply unlikeable. Honestly, I’m not trying to be purposefully mean in these reviews, I’m endeavouring to be honest with my personal pre-established moral code, and these readings really haven’t been very glorious.

Now, onto the last part of this book. Some israelites from the tribe of Benjamin raped an israelite woman, and for some reason instead of using the established laws, the other tribes decide to shun the Benjamites, refusing them any women from their tribe, forever…
But they’re still part of the same Israelite extended family, can’t just let the tribe die by attrition...hmmm...what a tricky situation, this calls for…

BIBLE TOP TIP!

If, like the Benjamites, your entire tribe is shunned by the rest of your people, and they won’t give you any wives willingly, listen to their suggestion: go sit in the cover of vineyards while a big feast to the lord is happening in a nearby city, and kidnap a bunch of women from there, then your tribe will have clean wives, and the other Israelites won’t have given them to you.
As you can see, looking for loopholes in your own morality and god’s laws is a long established tradition in Judaism.

Morality: 0/10

No genocides, but a whole heap of more minor immoral actions.

Book 6: Joshua

2019-04-17


Storytelling: 6/10

Joshua leads the israelites after Moses’ death, and he is basically Conan the barbarian.

First, he famously attacks Jericho, where seven of his priests sound trumpets for seven days, but it’s not until the last day that the trumpet sounds elicit a warcry from his army and that is what makes the walls fall. Stump your friends at bible trivia with this fun fact!
What follows is less fun. As god commanded, the israelites kill everything and everyone, burns and raze the city.

Next up, the city of Ai.
As god commanded, the israelites kill all 12 000 inhabitants, burns and raze the city. This is the only city that was given a population count, which we’ll use later to extrapolate some numbers.
I could go on listing cities and kings, as the book does for 13 chapters, but all in all, 31 kings and their peoples are exterminated. That's hundreds of thousands of humans systematically murdered for the glory of the jewish god.

I would have called this chapter “genocides”, there is nothing happy go lucky about the way Joshua made war.

Morality -31 / 10

After 31 genocides, Joshua was getting old, but he still half-heartedly conquers a few more lands, but, beware the half assery, for he does not exterminate in a way that pleases the lord.

The second half of the book, after chapter 13 is just a list of how to divide the conquered land amongst the Israelite tribes, including land still to be conquered.

BIBLE TOP TIP!

If you see an israelite army about to conduct holy war on you, pull a Gibeonite of them! Yoink! Surprise conversion! Accept their god unbidden, and you’ll only be enslaved instead of your entire civilisation erased from existence!

Book 5: Deuteronomy

2019-04-16
Finally, after 40 years of wandering, a plague, and a war; Moses is bringing the Israelites to their destination.

Storytelling: 7/10

The narration really picks up, with thrilling descriptions of war and plunder! It almost feels Tolkienian.

The first ten chapters (first 25% of the book) are good stuff...by biblical boredom standards. God speaks convincingly, mellows a bit, at least in word, and he promises the world to his chosen people. He gently reminds Moses of the commandments, and to be cool to foreigners in their new lands; this is followed by a restating of all the laws written about earlier.
The 1st commandment (worship only me, no other gods) is heavily emphasised, as always.

All in all, a good recap of previous books.This makes sense since it's supposed to be a second telling of past events and laws.
To all prospective bible readers, you can skip books 2, 3, 4 (exodus, leviticus, numbers)

Morality: 4/10

Chapter 20:
When attacking a city, offer peace, if they accept, BAM! free forced labour! If they resist, kill all men and plunder the rest. Oh but this is only for cities far away, for the promised land, hittites, jebusites, etc. kill and raze and burn everything.

After a very long list of laws (Hey that's ok, it was much less boring to read than any present day law text), comes warning about the consequences. Conveniently, there is no talk of divine smiting or other supernatural phenomena, only that your crops will die in you fields, enemies will conquer your town, your friends and family will shun you.
Even more cunningly, god predicts that his chosen people will lose faith in him, and bad things will happen to them, all of the above, as well as being driven into exile, back to Egypt in slavery, etc. And it will be the people’s fault for not being blind zealots.

God is really growing, he’s getting sneaky in establishing his precepts and warning about false prophets.

How bad would it be to live by these precepts? 

  1. You’re genetically Jewish, as long as you don’t break any rules, you’ll be rich and have many children
  2. You live among jews, the same laws apply to you, but you’ll probably be a servant or a slave.
  3. You don’t live with the jews, prepare to be invaded, forced into slavery or executed.
  4. You’re part of the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites or Jebusites: prepare for your genocide.
At the end of the book, Moses who was the first and only prophet so far, dies peacefully at the age of 120, as prescribed by the lord. Finally, we’ll be getting something new in the next book (cue derisive laughter of everyone who’s read further than me).

BIBLE TOP TIP!

Chapter 25:7-10

If you’re a widow, and your late husband’s brother won’t marry you, spit in his face and take one of his sandals.
[direct quote]That man’s line shall be known in Israel as The Family of the Unsandaled.

Book 4: Numbers

2019-04-15
From the title alone, you know you’re in for a wild ride. This has been the worst book to trudge through so far, it took me a week to read, compared to one day for previous books.

Let’s start with a census! Precise numbers of every tribe...with no dates given, so this is entirely pointless. And since consistency is for the dogs, let’s slather a few laws after this. Here’s one:
Law of jealousy: if a woman is suspected of adultery, but no proof exists, make her drink poison, and if she’s innocent, she’ll be fine. Oh yeah, this seems sensible and unbiased.

Since the tone is so inconsistent anyway, why not follow with an interminable list of who brought what offering (silver plates, lambs, goats, bulls, grain) at a certain point in time.
What makes the drudgery even worse are the filler words, each time repeating phrases like “males between the ages of 20 and 60” before each census number, “according to the sanctuary shekel” after every mention of shekel, and other convolutions.
Suddenly, the narration of Moses and friends in the desert continues. I knew the bible was a mish-mash of different semi-related books, I did not expect this random tapestry within the same book. 

Morality: 3/10

Most of the laws are just repeated from before, but there are some dick moves from god.

“We’re tired of eating manna from heaven, oh Lord!” OH YEAH!? Well how about I make it rain fish and meat on you so you can so much meat until you can’t take it anymore? HOW ABOUT YOU SMOKE A WHOLE CARTON OF CIGARETTES! Also, here’s a plague on you for being little whiners! Oh, this land I brought you to isn’t good enough? Fine, I’ll kill all of you!
Moses asks him to chill, and so god just sets them to wander the desert for 40 years.

“Apply the same laws to foreigners living among you as for yourselves” Well this is new, thumbs up.

Oh, but make sure nobody even tries to do anything but worship god in the exact way god demanded, or the israelites will get more plagues upon them. 24000 of them died before someone finally killed the unbeliever priest.

Storytelling: 2/10

To some, this book’s review may seem disjointed and borderline nonsensical. Maybe I’m an incompetent narrator, or maybe I’m emulating the chapter structure of this very book.

I will say this in defense of this chapter, it is called “numbers”, and numbers is what you get...holy crapola was it boring…

However, there is a talking donkey, that’s worth two points alone!

BIBLE TOP TIP!

I’m starting this new segment to replace the predictable “my belief in god=0” category.
You are only a murderer if you use an object made of metal or wood or stone to hit someone with with deadly intent, or throw something in order to kill a person.
Listen up bible literalist would-be killers, use a tungsten carbide shiv or an aluminium bat, it won't be murder.
To anyone writing a legal code, learn when to be specific and when to be broad.

Book 3: Leviticus

2019-04-10

Suitable reading for a role playing enthusiast wanting to play the part of an ancient judaic priest...If said player has the attention memory of a goldfish, because holy repetition, Batman!

The boredom, interminable. Some say repetition is the mother of learning, that doesn't mean textbooks need to be repetitive, redundant, rehashing, tautological and pleonasmic, even if repetition is the mother of all learning. I could have just read the same text again, no needed to actually write and publish it supernumerically.

Bear a thought for the poor scribe copying manuscripts before Gutenberg came along with his printing press!
Also there a lot of repetition in this book.

Morals: 6/10


On a positive note, there is a fair amount of rudimentary epidemiology (can't really call it medicine since no cures are discussed, only quarantines at best). It mainly pertains to judging whether a condition is likely to be serious and infectious (unclean) or benign (clean). There's a big emphasis on washing unclean things and men, so all in all, not too shabby for sand people from a few thousands years ago.

No incest, no fucking your neighbour's wife, no gay sex, no bestiality, no human sacrifices. I think divorce is OK, as long as no priest marries the woman afterwards.
Of course if you're a heathen and not descended from Abraham, then fuck off. You can't convert, you can at most be pals if you're circumcised.

In a nutshell, for people living thousands of years ago in the middle east, there is some reasonable advice mixed in with pointless rituals. However, please bear in mind the sum total of knowledge accumulated by mankind since then renders it obsolete.

Anyone who blindly follows these precepts and laws blindly in our day and age shall be put to death by stoning, for he is unclean.


My belief in god: still 0


You may have noticed I specifically talk about god, and not God, for in my eyes, he has not earned the majuscule.
In previous books, god was like a 2 year old, then a 6 year old. In Leviticus, god acts like a middle-schooler trying to pad the length of his essay to make it seem more impressive. At least he's maturing.

Since he was shown in Genesis not to be omniscient, it seems sensible that he gives incomplete but well meaning advice to his chosen people. Despite that, just to be safe, he ends the book by saying "if you don't do exactly as I tell you I will fuck your shit up". You know, like a middle-schooler preemptively getting angry when he realises his essay if full of holes and repetition.

Tl;dr: if you ever get stuck back in time, be a priest, you get to judge people all day long and get rich as guilty people will bring you livestock.

Storytelling: N/A


P.S. An adult man is worth 50 shekels of silver, according to the highest estimate by historians, that equals 50x17= 850g of silver. At the time of writing this review, that comes to 434x0.850 = 350€
An adult woman is only worth 60% of that.

So all those memes about income inequality and women only getting 77¢ on the dollar, get your estimates right next time.


Book 2: Exodus

2019-04-09

Morals: 4/10

The old commandments (eye for an eye etc.) seem fair enough, however, there are very heavy overtones of slavery and misogyny.

And if you're good Hebrews, god will kill or drive away all Hittites, Girgashites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites so you can have their land.

Storytelling: 7/10


Lots of things happen, the plagues of egypt, crossing the desert...but the tales could use more detail, and god never explains why he does anything.
The last third of the book is an interminable list of how to build a temple and how to worship there. My eyes glazed over for large portions of that. But in theory, it's valuable information as an instruction booklet, so I won't hold it against it.

My belief in this god: remains at 0


In genesis, god acted like a 2 year old, having temper tantrums.
In exodus, he acts like a 6 year old, he has a plan, but is too dumb to execute it efficiently, and forgets obvious details, like feeding people who he sent into a desert. Then gets mad when some of his chosen people don't blindly follow his bumbling footsteps.
In Genesis, he is shown to not be all-knowing, in exodus, he is shown to not be the only god.

Book1: Genesis

2019-04-08

Storytelling: 2/10

Some entertaining stories, drowned in a sea of pointless actuarial tables.

Provable historical facts: 1/10

Cities are named, which have existed, maybe but most things are assertions without proof. But this is all very ancient stuff, so I'll give the benefit of the doubt.

Morality: 0/10

God is a petulant spoiled brat, giving orders on fickle whims, without any logic or plan.


Hard focus on tribalism, excluding people different from the hero genealogical line, and encouraging dishonest trickery of people following other gods.

My belief in god:

Less than before reading this book. He is provably not omniscient in this book and his morals are garbage.