Friday, 14 June 2019

Book 19: Psalms (part 1/3)

Since this book is a collection of 150 psalms, each a self contained short prayer/poem, I'm going to try something different and summarise each psalm in one sentence. Sometimes I'll quote directly, as the theme is often expressed in the opening sentence of a psalm.

Most of these are supposed to be set to music, which is fun. However, I ran out of energy reading through all these, so I'll only be covering the first third for now.



1 god punishes the wicked
2 even if you are a king, be humble before god
3 god is David's shield
4 prayer for protection
5 prayer for righteous divine anger
6 prayer for mercy
7 prayer for help in battle
8 lord, how majestic is your name in all the earth!
9 thank you lord for smashing our enemies
10 reminder to god to pay attention and smite the wicked
11 the lord is righteous and loves justice (hilarious)
12 thanks for smiting the wicked, god
13 yo god, where you at?
14 fools and evil men say there is no god
15 only nice people get to live with god
16 I am happy because god is in my heart
17 seriously though, god, where you at?
18 "The Lord is my rock, my fortress and my deliverer;" he came and rescued me.
19 god is perfect
20 may the lord hear your prayers
21 thanks for the help in warfare, god
22 "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"
23 "The Lord is my shepherd, I lack nothing."
24 The earth is the lord's, so open your gates to him
25 god teach me, heal me, and rescue me
26 "Vindicate me, Lord, for I have led a blameless life"
27 god is my light, thanks for smiting my foes, can I get to heaven? Thanks for receiving me.
28 fine, I'll do my own dirty work of you don't show yourself.
29 god is very powerful
30 thanks for healing me, lord
31 ok, you still haven't showed up, but I still like you
32 sinner, remember to confess to god.
33 happy happy joy joy
34 praise the lord, fear the lord
35 lord, plz smite
36 unbelievers are cartoonishly evil
37 don't worry about unbelievers, for the lord will smite them
38 whoops, I did bad, and god was mad, sorry
39 repentance for having sinned
40 god heard me repenting and now all is fine
41 "Blessed are those who have regard for the weak"
42 god is cool and all, but where is he?
43 you're still not showing yourself, please smite my enemies
44 god, you used to lead us in glorious battle, but now you sleep, wake up
45 I love god and I also love fashion
46 god strong, god smash, god make fortress
47 be merry, for the lord has smashed our enemies.
48 god is mighty, and zion is a cool place.
49 "People who have wealth but lack understanding are like the beasts that perish."
50 "Consider this, you who forget God, or I will tear you to pieces, with no one to rescue you"


Did you really just read through a list of 50 random seeming psalm summaries? Boring and redundant, was it? Welcome to the bible.

My favourites are: 14, 22, 23, 47

In the first 50 psalms, about ⅓ are praising and thanking god, ⅓ are asking for help, ⅓ are reminding god to do his job.
Psalm 27 is a good summary of the whole thing.


Morality: 5/10


Some OK stuff, be good to others, protect the weak...on the other hand, please good, smite my enemies.


Storyteling: N/A


No story to speak of, but some psalms can be quite poetic. Only a fool like myself would force-feed himself this quantity of poetry in one go, opening this book at random and reading 1-2 psalms could be nice.



Paul 1970

When I find myself in times of trouble
Mother Mary comes to me
Speaking words of wisdom
Let it be

And in my hour of darkness
She is standing right in front of me
Speaking words of wisdom
Let it be




Wednesday, 12 June 2019

Book 18: Job

Job was a holy man, a rich man. Job had many sons, cattle and servants, in that order. So god and satan decide to play games with him.

Let's see how this book progresses, to see if in my eyes, satan deserves to get his name capitalised. A privilege that god has lost. "Of course he worships you" declares satan. "He lives the good life and has nothing to complain about! -Alright then" answers god. "Do what you will to his possessions and life, but don't touch the man himself". So in short order, Job's cattle were stolen, many of his servants killed, his sheep burned by fire from heaven, raiders stole his camels, his house collapsed upon his sons and daughters, killing then all. Job is not happy, but didn't blame god. The lord yeeteth, and the lord yoinketh. All this was told in a single chapter, very dense and interesting storytelling. Good job! Pun definitely intended. In book 2, satan easily convinces god that it was too easy, so he gets permission to fuck Job up physically as well, as long as satan doesn't kill him.

Seeing his husband covered in painful sores, Job's wife curses god and wishes Job would die instead of having to endure this. Of course, Job is too good for that. He still reveres god but his previously unshakeable faith is starting to waiver. Instead, Job curses the day he was born, but at first, leaves god blameless. He's a pretty good poet, I have to say, despite being disfigured by sores. Three friends of his manage to calm him down, reminding him of the original sin all men are born with. "Can a mortal be more righteous than god?"
Job figures, yup better with god than without any god, bit you can't trust friends. Why though, god? explain yourself! The book started well, but it devolves into discussions about the minutiae of being a good man, and addressing blame to one entity or another. It could, in theory, all be very fascinating, if the book didn't start with god and satan standing over the metaphorical anthill with a magnifying glass, and elbowing each other. In a nutshell, god is unknowable, so why bother being angry at him, or at your condition.

In any case, job is bitter at his miserable fate, and his friends abandon him for he speaks blasphemy. In his downtrodden state, he streets to see flaws in the blind worship of god. How come the wicked prisoner, while he. Who was so faithful, gets punished?
Job 21:19-21
It is said, ‘God stores up the punishment of the wicked for their children.’
Let him repay the wicked, so that they themselves will experience it!
let them drink the cup of the wrath of the Almighty.
Let their own eyes see their destruction;
For what do they care about the families they leave behind when their allotted months come to an end?

Ah, but like the child over the anthill, god knows no empathy toward the humans he created in his image, and arguably even now distressingly, god is a poor teacher.
No, no, you were probably wicked, says job's friend. To this accusation, Job answers:

Job 24:25
“If this is not so, who can prove me false
and reduce my words to nothing?”
You go Job! Use that brain! Be skeptical! But of course, he is answered by blind dogma. Job thinks of himself having being righteous and faithful all his life, and finds no understanding in his pox stricken condition. His friends stopped talking to him after that, but his debates weren't over yet. Job's words had angered Elihu, a younger man who was listening in. To be fair, he is more angry at Job's friends whose poor debating skills and over-reliance on repeating blind dogma failed to sway Job. Elihu berates him, and build up to a didactic argument. Oh this will be interesting!
Job 34:10-12
“So listen to me, you men of understanding.
Far be it from God to do evil,
He repays everyone for what they have done;
from the Almighty to do wrong.
It is unthinkable that God would do wrong,
he brings on them what their conduct deserves.
that the Almighty would pervert justice."
...Nevermind, it's just more blind dogma. Again, these arguments would hold up better if we didn't already know that god is doing all this just for fun with his buddy satan. Elihu continues, declaring that job must have been wicked, since good punishes the wicked (circular reasoning), god is a great teacher (erm, well this whole book is predicated on the notion that job isn't learning anything, despite honestly trying), god created the world and shows his power with lightning and snow (non-sequitur).
Job 37:23
The Almighty is beyond our reach and exalted in power;
in his justice and great righteousness, he does not oppress.
A perfect example of a catchy, but vapid and unsubstantiated claim.

GOD SPEAKS

Oh shit, chapter 38, suddenly god speaks to job out of the storm. So far we've been hearing his lackeys, here comes the head honcho himself. Let's dissect his words, shall we?

Job 38:2-3
“Who is this that obscures my plans
with words without knowledge?

I will question you,
Brace yourself like a man;
and you shall answer me.

God goes on to describe his grand works for two full chapters. However, at no point did Job say he were as mighty as god, or that god doesn't exist. So I guess this is a sort of strawman mixed with poisoning the well, mixed with character assassination.
Job obviously has no answer, so stays humble. God continues:
Job 40:8-9

“Would you discredit my justice?
Would you condemn me to justify yourself?

Ah, here we go, finally on topic
Do you have an arm like God’s?
and can your voice thunder like his?


Dammit...no. It's just more boasting. God spends two more chapters describing how cool elephants are...I mean, yeah, I agree, elephants are pretty cool, but is this the best use of your time, oh creator of the universe?
Its snorting throws out flashes of light;
its eyes are like the rays of dawn.
sparks of fire shoot out.
Flames stream from its mouth;
Smoke pours from its nostrils
no purpose of yours can be thwarted.
as from a boiling pot over burning reeds.
Actually, maybe he's not talking about elephants. Still, can we get back on topic? Wisdom, justice?
Job 42:1-6
Then Job replied to the Lord:
“I know that you can do all things;
My ears had heard of you

You asked, ‘Who is this that obscures my plans without knowledge?’
Surely I spoke of things I did not understand,
“You said, ‘Listen now, and I will speak;
things too wonderful for me to know.
I will question you,
and you shall answer me.’
but now my eyes have seen you.
Therefore I despise myself
and repent in dust and ashes.”
This is all that job answered to god, not a single word more.
So job is forgiven His three friends who failed to talk him over are punished, and job ends up twice as rich as he was before all this.

OK, seeing is believing, but...justice? Wisdom? Judgement? Does god have nothing else besides terror to offer?
WHAT THE FUCK WAS THE POINT OF ALL THIS!?


Bible top tip

Shut up and do as you're told. Don't wait for explanations and above all, don't try thinking independently, or the giant bully in the sky will slap you down.

Morality: 0/10

The entire drawn out message here is "don't you dare using reason, god is stronger than you, do as he says". It'd be useless for me to do a methodical point by point analysis.

Storytelling: 9/10

Despite the depressing ending (you are an ant, beware the giant child with a looking glass looking over you), and despite some boring parts in the middle due to bad debaters and repetition (the bible loves repetition), it's quite an interesting read.
Job has glimpses of reason and critical thinking, but sadly they are dashed in the end.
Before I'd read this myself, I only knew the short version of the sorry, I thought job was just a holy man from beginning to end, and no suffering had sway on him. The real version is a lot more interesting...But the lesson being taught is just as asinine as in the shorter pop culture version.

How cool is satan? Does he deserve to be called Satan?

Eh, too early to tell, all he really did was play with god. His evil is about on par with god in this one.

Friday, 7 June 2019

Book 17: Esther

During the time of the Persian king Xerxes, who reigned from India to Cush.

Xerxes has a big party, gets drunk, wants to show everyone his pretty queen wife, but she refuses. So of course, he cries  "of her head!" then and there. No, wait. Instead, he consults with his cadre of councillors, law experts and wise men, how about that! Go Xerxes!

The royal wife is subsequently stripped of her glory (non-metaphorically) and is never allowed in the presence of the king again. This new law is sent our throughout the land, so all households will have respectful women who know their place, under threat of being cast our of their families.

The plot is threaded



Xerxes now needs a new hot wife, so he sends out men to look for his new Cinderella. As the title of the book suggests, the Jewish Esther, daughter of Mordecai is among the candidates.
Horny though he may be, Xerxes had the patience of a saint: Before meeting with him and spending the night, every girl undergoes 12 months of beauty treatments in the harem, daily anointment with perfumed oils and other girly pamperings.
Naturally, when Esther's turn comes, she awes and woos the king, who decides to make her queen on the spot.
Oh, but a plot thread is still unknown to the king Xerxes...that of Esther's Jewish lineage! Dun dun duuuun.


And now, how about a brief commercial message from our sponsor:
Is your wife too lazy or incompetent to cook for you? Buy a monthly subscription to Yummy-Moses-box, and receive mana from heaven every day in the mail! Use offer code YAHWEH for 66% off your first order!
Back to our regularly scheduled soap opera.


Esther gains ever more favours a she warns her new husband about an assassination plot, with the help of he father moredcai.

A villain emerges



Mordecai draws the ire of Haman, a nobleman, by refusing to bow to him. When Haman in his fury hears of mordecai's Jewish roots, he decides the death of one man is not enough, and convinces his king Xerxes to a full shoah.

On the 13th day of the 10th month, all Jews will be exterminated, young and old, women and children.

dramatic music swells

The methodical organisation and set date was a good plan, but having it literally shouted on the rooftops was not, as of course, the Jews also hear of their planned execution date.

Mordecai and Esther hatch a plan for her to talk the king out of this genocide. Although it is forbidden to approach the king unless summoned, she uses her feminine wiles to invite him to a small banquet, along with Haman. As Xerxes is still smitten with her, he vows not to refuse her anything, up to and including half the kingdom is so asked.

In true soap-opera timing, Haman is building a gallows to hang Mordecai and approaches Xerxes to tell him about it, while precisely at the same moment, Xerxes is reading the chronicles of his reign and remembers he never rewarded Mordecai for thwarting the plot on his life.

Esther 6:6-10
When Haman entered, the king asked him, “What should be done for the man the king delights to honor?”

Now Haman thought to himself, “Who is there that the king would rather honor than me?” 
So he answered the king, “For the man the king delights to honor, 8 have them bring a royal robe the king has worn and a horse the king has ridden, one with a royal crest placed on its head.
Then let the robe and horse be entrusted to one of the king’s most noble princes. Let them robe the man the king delights to honor, and lead him on the horse through the city streets, proclaiming before him, ‘This is what is done for the man the king delights to honor!’”

“Go at once,” the king commanded Haman. “Get the robe and the horse and do just as you have suggested for Mordecai the Jew, who sits at the king’s gate. Do not neglect anything you have recommended.”



On the next day, Esther, Xerxes and Haman are lounging, drinking wine. Esther asks for her life, and that of her people to be spared, being quite noncommittal as to who her people are.
"Who ordered this killing?
-Haman
-hang him on the gallows meant for Mordecai"
bim bam done.

This version I've been reading is strangely sanitised in parts. In the original texts, hanging was actually impaling on a spike.

Final crescendo


So Xerxes, seing his folly, publishes a new royal edict, freeing the Jews, and giving them the right to defend themselves.
Since royal edicts are immutable, Xerxes couldn't take back his previous order to exterminate the Jews, and this new edict was the next best thing. What a strangely ineffective way to rule an empire.

Many people of other nationalities became Jews because fear of the Jews has seized them, this may or may not save them in the end, depending which book they are written about in.

Having royal permission to defend themselves, the Jews fought and killed other people in the same kingdom, mostly but not exclusivity hunting down the sons of Haman. In the end, 75 000 were killed.

In any case, the ensuing celebrations were enshrined into the Jewish calendar as the Purim, a yearly days of merriment, to stand for all times. Hooray for celebrating civil wars!

Storytelling 10/10 soap opera


It was a delightfully silly interlude, even according to serious bible scholars.

Morality: N/A


This is just a silly side-story. God isn't even on the casting list.

Wednesday, 5 June 2019

Book 16: Nehemiah

So there's this dude, he's called Nehemiah, he likes to pray and write biblical texts in the first person.

Dude asks king Artaxerxes for permission to leave for Jerusalem, and a stipend to rebuild it...hang on a second, didn't we just cover this in the last book, Ezra, as well as at the end of 2 Chronicles? So it's going to be one of those books again, eh? YMR. Yet More Repetition.
Except, [frantically double checks information] It was supposed to be king Cyrus, and then, Xerxes and Artaxerxes wer against it, but hang on, in the bible, Darius came after those X-men...maybe it was Darius 2? ARGH! The bible is a garbage book for learning history. And history is all it's been trying to teach for the last several hundred pages!
Achaemenid kingdom timeline, from wikipedia.

Moving back to the text of the bible, a bunch of people repaired a bunch of buildings, along with more and more of the outer walls, while the Ammonites, Arabs and other outsiders laughed at the Jewish workmanship.

The grumbling of outsiders grow louder as Jerusalem's walls grow taller. So the Israelites start posting armed guards and generally behaving like stereotypical present day redneck US sovereign citizens. Lots of weapons, grumbling about how taxes are illegal, complaining about foreigners, invoking god anytime anyone steps out of line...and of course, their main driving force is building a wall.



Since the main peculiarity of this book is it being written in the first person, it gives occasion for Nehemiah to delight in self praise. Oh he's the governor, but takers no pay, instead everyone can eat at his table. Oh he's so holy, so cunning, so good, god help us all, he's so great. He has the best prayers, the best words, some of the words, you can't even understand how much the best they are. Don't read the fake news, just read the bible, because Nehemiah wrote this part, and it's the best part.

Eventually, the walls were completed and more meticulously listed Jews came to Jerusalem.

Following that great achievement, chapter 9 in book of Nehemiah is a transcription of a prayer uttered at the somber ceremonies for the wall. The priests decided to outdo themselves, and recited a summary of all events that have happened to the Jewish people since Moses.
I won't paste it in here, but you can read it for yourself if for some reason you want a quick recap of the several hundreds years leading up to this point.
The even more BASIC version is:

10 God nice
20 man betray
30 god angry
40 man repent
50 GOTO 10

With great pomp and ceremony, the people of Jerusalem make a written contract with god, promising a rigid adherence to the old laws and no more screwups.
All the tribal leaders of Israel, Benjamin and Judah (i.e all the Jews) come to live in Jerusalem, along with 10 % of all Jews, families chosen at random, but it's mostly Judeans.
Reminder, Israelites don't traditionally live in Jerusalem, it's a city of Judah and Benjamin.

Much rejoicing and partying follows, as the old law of Moses are starting to be strongly enforced once again. Three is no mention of punishments, but by god, nobody will do anything on the Sabbath, that's for sure.

Storytelling: 8/10


Despite the long lists of people and peoples, imagining everyone as US rednecks really kept me entertained, and the succinct good recap of everything in chapters 9 is the cherry on top.

Morality: 7/10


Stretching my credulity to its breaking point, and assuming this first person narration to be trustworthy...what am I saying, this is the bible, everything is hearsay...the morality is pretty good, no warmongering, a return to solid old laws.